Ideas for Acumatica

Feedback processing: We do not reply to all messages, but we do read them, analyze them, and work to improve Acumatica based on the feedback we receive. Ideas and comments may not appear immediately. Some legitimate ideas are flagged as spam and will be added when we review the spam folders.
Content: This portal is for product ideas and feedback only. If you need customer service assistance, contact your Acumatica Support Partner, submit a support case, or get assistance from community resources: LinkedIn Group or StackOverflow
No Reliance: Information is maintained on a best-efforts basis and may be changed without notice. Acumatica cannot guarantee the accuracy of the information provided or guarantee completion of features/ideas described on this portal.

Approval/ Rejection should allow approver to enter reason

When approving/ rejecting a document, the approver should be able to enter a reason. In case of a Reject, the reason should be mandatory

Approval Reasons  should also be shown on the 'Approval Details' section of the document

  • Angelo Pickard
  • Aug 28 2017
  • Shipped
  • Attach files
  • Angelo Pickard commented
    August 14, 2019 05:38

    Is it possible to consider extending this feature either to all all approval maps or at least to the following:

    - PR/ PO

    - Bills and Adjustments

    - SO


  • Derek Cote commented
    August 13, 2019 19:06

    Hi @Doug, do you have any information as to the extension of this functionality to PR/PO and SO screens?

  • Douglas Johnson commented
    March 27, 2019 00:28

    @Angelo - only the approval map items in my prior post are supported. This does not include PO and SO approval maps.

  • Angelo Pickard commented
    March 26, 2019 23:32

    Thanks Douglas,

    Much appreciate the fact that our ideas are considered. 

    One quick question as I did not have time to try this out yet. Is this also extended to PR/ PO and SO approval maps?

  • Douglas Johnson commented
    March 26, 2019 14:51

    Shipped (for most use cases):

    In 2019 R1 you can require approvers to include reasons for approving and/or rejecting documents. These documents include change orders, employee time cards, equipment time cards, expense claims, pro forma invoices, project quotes, and sales quotes. 

  • david spennacchio commented
    February 15, 2019 13:57

    Is this setup yet?  I don't see a place to enter comments when approving or rejecting.  Rejection should Require a comment.  Approval comment should be optional.

  • Angelo Pickard commented
    August 27, 2018 05:14

    Thanks Acumatica! Eager to see this minor yet important feature as part of standard Acumatica 

  • Mike Lupro commented
    May 29, 2018 21:53

    Glad my post triggered a response.  Thanks for the future consideration flag Acumatica!

  • Angelo Pickard commented
    May 28, 2018 06:44

    Thanks Mike,

    Your description of the solution is exactly what I was looking for when I originally posted this idea. All of our clients using Approval ask for this feature and currently the only way to address this feature is through customization. The workaround of adding a comment in the 'Notes' section of the document being rejected is not practical.

    Just received feedback from Acumatica that this will be considered in the future, good to be listened to. Unfortunately there will not be an out of the box solution for the time being.

    If Acumatica or anybody else thinks of any practical workaround, please share 

  • Mike Lupro commented
    May 25, 2018 13:09

    Why are there no comments from Acumatica on this popular idea?  Is there a work-around that makes this idea moot?  I personally think that an approval-rejection (an oxymoron for sure) NEEDS  a reason - from a list of reasons (checkbox) and an OPTION to comment back to the original data-entry person.